I take a little different tact then several of the other active posters on these boards.
Yes, most of the various god ideas I have heard cannot be proven or disproven.
That said, it does not mean that both negation and positivity of any particular god idea is on equal footing.
An old favorite example of mine, that I have stated on these boards a lot is:
You owe me 1 million dollars. Prove that you do not. Most folks here, (especially atheist!) quickly realize, they can not prove that they do not owe me 1 million dollars. And they point out correctly, no, the burden of proof lies on me, I need to prove that you owe me 1 million dollars. Not the other way around.
Naturally, I am unable to prove that you owe me 1 million dollars. So we have a scenario much like “god” where one side is not able to conclusively “prove” their point of view. Does that mean we enter a sort of halfway point? Do we compromise and say well, neither side can prove it, so we will say we are both half right and you pay me 500,000 dollars?
NO! Of course not! Who would agree to that?? Are you prepared to pay me 500,000 dollars? Is anyone? Why not?
We can wholesale reject any unproven idea. Not only that, but we should. No one has to prove there is no god, or prove they do not owe me 1 million dollars, they can reject it, and they do not even have to say why or defend their position.
Not only that, other people should help to make sure that I am not going around demanding 1 million dollars from people, and brow beat people into my way of thinking by saying “you can’t prove that you do not owe me money,” (or that my particular god idea flavor does not exist.)
Instead, we should simply place an unproven idea exactly where it belongs. Just another random (crazy!) idea that is so unsupported it can be dismissed out of hand, no argument needed. As so many of us say here, come back when you have actual testable real world evidence, or it just another random human generated idea that has no bearing on reality.
I also want to add in here: the extremely vague notion of a general “god” idea has gotten so incredibly vague that the blanket statement of: “is there a god or not” is actually nearly meaningless, a waste of words it is so vague, nearly any definition could fill in that word, making it so ambiguous it is barely a word to be used in communication.
de·i·ty
/ˈdēədē,ˈdāədē/
noun
- a god or goddess (in a polytheistic religion).
“a deity of ancient Greece”
-
divine status, quality, or nature.
-
the creator and supreme being
Naturally a loop back to the word god. And as I said another very vague word.
So we are forced to take my own opinion of what the word deity means.
I will say: our sun is a deity. Does it care about humans? Nope. Does it “care” about anything? nope. But it certainly is powerful and absolutely necessary for life and us being here, being able to type on these boards etc.