Why do you believe any deity, or deities exist? Please provide the best reason / evidence first

Not to argue semantics, but I think this is where words matter. Seeking truth is not the same as seeking an answer.

Seeking truth is process oriented, where seeking an answer is goal oriented.

Both suffer from subjectivity. Truth is subject to perception. Answers are subject to purpose.

Facts are like the raw material required for validation. An absolute truth is no longer absolute when it is missing facts. An answer does not suffer that limitation.

1 Like

I’m not convinced he understands moral objectivism, relativism, or subjectivism.

I don’t think I’ve ever heard this put so succinctly and clearly. Thanks for this.

You are welcome. Honestly, I learned this from 25 years working with troubled horses.

1 Like

That’s interesting, cynical1.

Applying logic to what you say, since Christianity requires its followers to believe without evidence…

John 20 : 29
Then Jesus told him, “Because you have seen me, you have believed; blessed are those who have not seen and yet have believed.”

…then JustCurious can’t claim that the Bible contains absolute truth. (Not that he has yet.)

Because it’s not just facts that are missing from the equation, evidence is too.

But perhaps we shouldn’t be so surprised at that. After all, the apostle Paul wrote this…

Corinthians 13 : 12
For now we see only a reflection as in a mirror; then we shall see face to face. Now I know in part; then I shall know fully, even as I am fully known.

At least he seems to have understood that absolute truth isn’t to be found in this life and nowhere on Earth.

Thank you,

Walter.

Depends on who you ask, and when you ask them. Catholic church couldn’t get enough of Hitler, until he lost. Now they will tell you about how bad he was and how no real Christians would have followed him.

2 Likes

Just thought I’d drop in during the lunch hour; so, have to run again–but cynical1 I’d be interested in hearing more about your 25 years of working with troubled horses. It’s a shame that we human beings aren’t that easy to work with. :+1: :rofl:

Talk to you all later. Hope you’re having a good day.

Great discussion, guys, and right-on-target: because none of us–absolutely none of us (including me)–has a corner market on truth. There’s a Cause and we see its effects: which should cause us to confess our ignorance and be like a little child (years ago) who’d look up into the sky at night and go “Wowwww!” instead of talking about black holes, how far it is between stars (around 30 trillion miles), etc.

Yes, in my simple, peanut brain I admit that this is all “beyond” me and, like Paul, say we only “see through a glass dimly:” especially when we see all Truth as revelation instead of discovery. :slight_smile:

Confess our ignorance, be like a little child AND don’t ignore or deny the evidence.

Because responsible adults should discipline their children not to ignore or deny the evidence.

Yes?

You’re exactly right, Walter: and that’s why “the heavens declare the Glory of God” and serve as evidence of His existence and creative design.

Gotta run. Thanks again for letting me be a part of your discussion group–and for not beating me up too badly. :laughing: :blush:

I thought about what you did here yesterday and today, JC.

It’s like a child at school being asked by the teacher what the capital of France is. The child says Berlin and the teacher corrects the child with the evidence. The following day the teacher asks the same child the same question and child, even though it’s been shown the evidence, stubbornly answers, Berlin.

That’s what happened here. Yesterday you were shown evidence and today, like that stubborn child, you’ve persisted in ignoring and denying it.

It seems that the child in question has closed it’s mind to the evidence, preferring what it wants to be true and not letting the evidence decide what is true.

1 Like

If that is what you consider evidence; then your standards are simply MUCH lower than mine. I’d wager they are artificially low (I’d wager you are not this credulous in the other aspects of your life). I certainly hope so. If not: would you be interested in an investment opportunity in a Moon bridge?

2 Likes

The evidence says otherwise, JC.

But we have seen how your mind is closed to the evidence that says otherwise.

1 Like

You’re exactly right, Walter: and that’s why “the heavens declare the Glory of God” and serve as evidence of His existence and creative design.

Which you see only by faith and not by any evidence.

If I’m exactly right in what I said you should look at the evidence and not make the decision on faith alone.

It’s obviously possible to believe things using faith that aren’t true. So obviously faith is a poor reason on which to base belief, since it doesn’t help us verify the veracity of claims.

But, Sheldon, it seems to me that it takes more faith to be an atheist than it does to be a theist. Sorry, I was heading out the door, but took one more look and saw your post. Thanks for writing! Later.

Well, we’re back to circular reasoning, Walter, because you believe things are so because you see them (a materialist view) whereas I believe because I know that none of this happened by accident or coincidence (a spiritual view). We’re talking about the same thing, but differing in what caused it all.

Gotta run. Later.

that isn’t a serious argument, that is a soundbite. i don’t think you are serious. bye

1 Like

How? Who told you that? Based on what?