Wrong. First of all, the papers I cited above postulate an eternally existing spacetime, within which the requisite processes take place. The assertion that the instantiation of the universe must take place âoutsideâ spacetime is a blind mythology fanboy assertion, and nothing more.
Again wrong. Try reading the actual scientific papers in question instead of wasting time with mythology and apologetics.
Bad news for you - physicists have already done this.
For example, physicists can calculate the temperature of the early universe, by taking note of the fact that the cosmic microwave background (henceforh, CMB for short) has been cosmologically red-shifted since the initial radiation was emitted. That radiation was originally emitted as infrared radiation (see below for the calculation), and there is a known precise relationship between the thermal temperature of matter, and the radiation it emits. Apparently you slept through your physics classes.
First, the relationship between wavelength and cosmological redshift is given by the following formula:
z = (λobsv/λemit) - 1
where λobsv is the observed wavelength at the present time, and λemit is the wavelength at which the radiation was emitted (by a now distant appropriate entity). It transpires that for the cosmic microwave background, the cosmological redshift z is approximately 1,091. Rearranging the above formula gives us:
λemit = λobsv/(z + 1)
Feeding in the peak wavelength of 1.063 mm (1.063 à 10-3 m) for λobsv, and 1091 for z, we have:
λemit = 9.7 à 10-7
This corresponds to an emitted wavelength of 970 nanometres, which is squarely in the infra-red. Courtesy of Wienâs Displacement law, this corresponds to a temperature of:
T = (2.897 à 10-3)/λemit = 2976 K.
The CMB was emitted approximately 379,000 years after the Big Bang, when the universe had cooled to a point where stable neutral atoms of hydrogen could form, and thus the universe became transparent to long range propagation of photons.
Indeed, you will find, in the requisite literature, frequent references to the temperature corresponding to the energies utilised in particle accelerator experiments. One electron volt (the standard unit used to measure particle accelerator energies) corresponds to a thermal temperature of approximately 11,604 K. The Large Hadron Collider, when it operates at its maximum possible energy of 14 TeV, will produce an effective temperature within the collision confinement region of 1.624 Ă 1017 K. This would, according to Wienâs displacement law, correspond to a photon wavelength of 1.783 Ă 10-20 m, which is well into the highest energy gamma ray part of the EM spectrum, and would be the sort of temperature expected to be present around 10-6 seconds after the Big Bang (temperature at T=10-43 seconds was 1032 K).
You can find out more about the relevant physics here, and a little of the known history of the universe here.
Enjoy being humiliated in this manner, do you?